Rye and dark amaro give the Manhattan a deeper, bittersweet silhouette.
At a Glance
Rye and dark amaro give the Manhattan a deeper, bittersweet silhouette. Amaro takes the place of sweet vermouth, lending the rye a dark, aromatic finish that feels both familiar and newly complex.
Creator & Origins
Bartender Todd Smith created the Black Manhattan in San Francisco in 2005, associated with Bourbon & Branch. Replacing sweet vermouth with Amaro Averna transformed the classic Manhattan’s sweet-wine profile into a darker herbal bitterness. Some later articles incorrectly date the drink to 2015, a decade after the accepted origin. The recognizable original uses Averna specifically; other amari produce legitimate riffs, not exact historical reproductions. We use rye for a firm spice backbone, though whiskey choices vary among modern interpretations.
Source & Editorial Status
Private staging design review. Publication approval not granted.
Black Manhattan
At a Glance
Ingredients
60 ml (2 oz) rye whiskey
30 ml (1 oz) Amaro Averna
1 dash aromatic bitters
1 dash orange bitters
Garnish: 1 brandied cherry
Instructions
Stir the rye, Averna and both bitters over plenty of hard ice until cold and glossy.
Strain into a chilled stemmed glass; the drink should arrive dark, clear and spirit-forward.
Drop in one good brandied cherry—nothing else is needed.